Peanut Butter Catering Pail

$27.99 or from $25.19 / month

(80 customer reviews)


Forty Thieves Peanut Butter is made from hi-oleic, non-GMO peanuts grown in Argentina.


This naturally sweet, protein-packed variety is dry-roasted in small batches and is available in either a smooth or crunchy texture. With no added sugar, oil or preservatives, it’s the perfect addition to whole-food baking, smoothies, dipping sauces and stir-fry sauces. 


Please note:

Peanut Butter Smooth is made with 100% hi-oleic, non-GMO peanuts. 

Peanut Butter Crunchy is made with hi-oleic, non-GMO peanuts and a touch of salt.

Available in 2kg, 4kg, 10kg.


Forty Thieves Peanut Butter Catering Pails are:


Made with 100% Natural High-Quality Ingredients. 

  • Peanut Butter Smooth: Made with 100% hi-oleic, non-GMO peanuts.
  • Peanut Butter Crunchy: Made with hi-oleic, non-GMO peanuts and a touch of salt.

There are no preservatives, refined sugars, emulsifiers or other cheap fillers.


Made to order with complete care

Your pail of Peanut Butter will always arrive fresh, full of flavour and without a thick layer of oil on the top. We always want to deliver quality, healthy products with the utmost care.


Healthy yet incredibly indulgent

Forty Thieves Peanut Butter is healthy, creamy and super versatile. Try sprucing up salads with a satay dressing, adding to smoothies or making high-protein peanut desserts.


Proudly NZ-owned and made

Forty Thieves is an artisan producer from the sunny Hibiscus Coast. We love working alongside creative Kiwis to transform our butters into new, unique creations. So get creative with our delicious Peanut Butter pails!

Add our Peanut Butter to your menu:

  • Serve as a delicious spread with fresh fruit like the classic combo of sliced banana on toast, sourdough or bagels
  • A key ingredient for extra protein in creamy smoothies and milkshakes with ingredients such as banana, cacao, cinnamon or oats
  • Perfect for healthy baking and vegan slices. Raw ‘snickers’ and caramel slices are always a big hit!
  • Spruce up salads with a rich peanut satay dressing, full of flavour.
  • Peanut Butter and chocolate bliss balls are a popular, healthy treat.
  • Rich plant-based dipping sauces like spicy, peanut satay sauce
Pail size (kg)

2kg, 4kg, 10kg


Smooth, Crunchy

80 reviews for Peanut Butter Catering Pail

  1. Alicia (verified owner)

    I ordered a 2kg tub about a month ago and it was DELICIOUS! Then I decided to order another one and it’s just not the same quality… it’s more ‘frothy’. Not as happy with it but I assume I just got a bad batch 🤷‍♀️ . I would highly recommend forty thieves though all the small jars I’ve purchased have been top notch!

    • Shyr Godfrey

      Hey! Thanks for your feedback and great to hear you are a big fan of our nut butters.

      The ‘frothy’ effect will have happened in transit. Give it a good stir and you should see that it will be back to your desired texture.

  2. Sam Johnston (verified owner)

    Ordering my 5th pail of peanut butter, so good thank you forty thieves!! You make my tummy very happy! =)

    • Brent Godfrey

      Wow! Now, that is super impressive – if there was ever a crown for consumption of FT PB pails you have definitely earned it! There are so many ways to eat PB – what’s your favourite go to? Thanks for the great feedback and for being such a fan! 🙂

  3. Melinda Foster (verified owner)

    Our family has consumed quite a few of these pails now – totally delicious every time and so easy to order with quick delivery! Thanks!!

  4. Diane (verified owner)

    Big fan of your pails of peanut butter. Makes a great spread. But my favourite way to demolish with pleasure is simply off the spoon. Fills you up and keeps you going.

  5. Yvette Campbell (verified owner)

    Huge fans of Forty Thieves Crunchy Peanut Butter, we use it in our breakfast smoothies, on toast, for long distance run training pinched into dates.
    Great product, fantastic price and super delicious to eat.

  6. Graham (verified owner)

    The Peanut Butter pail is my go to for making sure I have this deliciousness in the house for whenever I need it. My favourite is Crunchy and it goes great on toast, with my breakfast granola or straight of the spoon.

  7. adele (verified owner)

    love the crunchy peanut butter, I can”t believe how much we go thru its sooo good!

  8. Toshimi (verified owner)

    We have been on a monthly 4kg PB pail subscription for almost a year. It is great value and very tasty!

    • Brent Godfrey

      Thanks for being such a loyal fan and for the awesome feedback!

  9. Rob Moes (verified owner)

    Have ordered more than 10 pails of PB and also some almond, cashew etc.
    All have been excellent quality and they are highly recommended.

  10. Pam Turner (verified owner)

    Forty Thieves is the family’s favourite crunchy – we now order 2 litre pails (and put into smaller jars). Excellent customer service – the pail lid had come off in a recent order, (a very greasy and stained box from the courier) and Dayna at Forty thieves organised returning it, and sent out a replacement.

  11. Ashley Ward (verified owner)

    Currently up to our third 2kg pail of crunchy peanut butter. We are huge fans of peanut butter, and this is the best one out there. Been using it to make flourless cookies and mug cakes, and having on toast and spoonfuls out of the pail. Highly recommend getting it for peanut butter lovers out there

  12. Mary Hanna (verified owner)

    With a teenage PB addict in the house Forty Thieves is my tried and true way of a) keeping sanity and b) not going broke. Quick service, awesome product and good pricing is the winning trifecta. Thanks team 🙂

  13. Sue Young (verified owner)

    Yummy and great value

  14. Brenda Won (verified owner)

    We aren’t caterers but we love this peanut butter. It’s great value for money and great quality.

  15. Jo Smith (verified owner)

    Forty Thieves peanut crunchy peanut butter is the absolute best there is. The pails are great value for money and service is always super quick. My dog loves to lick out the what’s left of the empty pail at the end as well 🙂

    • Brent Godfrey

      Nice cleaning tip for your pails! That’s ingenious and I am sure it keeps your furry friend occupied for hours too 🙂
      Thanks for the lovely review.

  16. H Flanagan (verified owner)

    Great value and super fast and friendly service and shipping, ordering these pails from Forty Thieves qualifies as a life hack in my view

  17. David (verified owner)

    Fantastic taste and consistency. Arrives quickly. World class!

  18. Emily Mercer (verified owner)

    Eat this by the spoonful all the time. 2kg pail is great value.

  19. Kana (verified owner)

    It’s the first time to purchase a pail of PB.
    Good value. Tasty PB.

  20. Naresh (verified owner)

    Tried so many PB before from many different brands, but forty thieves is the best so far. Will definitely buy again👍

  21. SC (verified owner)

    Love the taste and texture of forty thieves. I used the PB mostly for baking so really great I can order in bulk.

  22. Rose Bainbridge (verified owner)

    Am not in catering but buy this as me and my kids LOVE this. Best tasting peanut better made

  23. Sam Leonard (verified owner)

    We go through so much peanut butter and this is definitely the best value and quality that you can get. There’s not really food in our house anymore, just various vehicles to deliver peanut butter into our mouths 😅

  24. Amanda (verified owner)

    Our family loves this on toast, apples in baking, in smoothies, by the spoonful yum! We are big fans… we buy the 4kg pail, great taste and value.

  25. Natalie (verified owner)

    My partner and I get the 10kg pail as we eat a lot of peanut butter. This peanut butter tastes so good and it’s also great value for money.

  26. Stacy, Jared & Woodsy Beans (verified owner)

    We have ordered a couple pails of PB this year and we’re super grateful to be able to buy this amazing local product in bulk. Highly recommend!

  27. Shirley Lynch (verified owner)

    I have been using Forty Thieves crunchy peanut butter for a couple of years to make peanut butter balls. Forty Thieves is a perfect butter for this and lots of other recipes. Delivery is quick and efficient. Couldn’t ask for a better product or service.

  28. Max Sharpe (verified owner)

    I go through lots of peanut butter and was looking for a good quality PB that I could order in high volumes… the 4 kg is perfect for me and ships out within a day!! Amazing product

  29. Richard (verified owner)

    It is frightening how quickly I can make my way through a 4kg pail of crunchy PB.
    The best there is!

  30. Tim Lindley

    If more than 5 stars were offered I would give more, I just love this stuff – its very high quality and I have no trouble getting through a 4kg pail at regular intervals. Its crunchy, has a good quantity of healthy oils, and tastes great – not too salty.

  31. Alice Barach (verified owner)

    Love this peanut butter! So tasty, and quick delivery. I might have to increase my bucket size to 10kg next time!

  32. Ana watling (verified owner)

    Delicious, delicious, delicious- fast prompt delivery😊 my favourite peanut butter

  33. Bex (verified owner)

    Love the not quite smooth texture, so delicious. Will be recommending to friends and ordering again for sure.

  34. Lynda (verified owner)

    Delicious! Nicely chunky, could do with a tad more salt though.

  35. Tim Lindley (verified owner)

    I have been buying catering pails for a while now – crunchy for home use and smooth for our food business, Forty Thieves nut butters are simply the best: great nutrition with plenty of healthy nut oils, and taste and texture superb. Please don’t add salt!

  36. frank gates (verified owner)

    Had to order a 2 KG CATERING PAIL to get us thru to our next monthly subscription 4 KG,.. why i hear you ask..because my wife and kids keep hitting the box as soon as it arrives with a fist full of dates and spoons in hand, total peanut butter carnage, So awesome job team, highly recommend.

  37. Sue Dromgool (verified owner)

    My husband loves your crunchy 2kg pail peanut butter on my sourdough, every morning its a treat…one slice your peanut butter the other honey from my hives all with coffee and a view. Arrives super quick even rural…the Almond butter I use in my healthy slice I pop in the freezer for my AirBNB guests….they love it and are always asking for the receipe…..highly recommend

  38. Uma (verified owner)

    Great product..

  39. Matt Sharp

    Just phenomenal – these PB pails are perfect for a PB LOVER like myself. Can’t get enough of them – I order a new 4 kg one every 1.5 months just for me!

  40. Warren Kaler (verified owner)

    After my daughter gave me a bucket for my birthday a few years ago, I have become addicted and now eat it every day. It is absolutely the best peanut butter, and I’ve tried them all.

  41. Michelle (verified owner)

    Excellent peanut butter and convenient delivery. Our family loves it!

  42. Monica (verified owner)

    Super yum, great texture

  43. Chris (verified owner)

    The only thing I love more than my 4kg pail of peanut butter is the looks o get when friends come over, I open the “paint bucket” on my bench and take a big spoonful out. Only issue is the amount of spoons I have to wash a day …

  44. Brett (verified owner)

    I thought 4kgs of peanut butter would suffice but due to the delicious nature I was mistaken and should have ordered more!

  45. Faye hudson (verified owner)

    Great value for money!

  46. susan fletcher (verified owner)

    First time buyer and very impressed , great speedy service and a great product . Will buy again and have told friends .

  47. Lisa Cross (verified owner)

    Amazingly Delicious! Great price too. My fussy peanut butter eater loves it. Now to see how long 2kg lasts. 🙂

  48. Ed (verified owner)

    Good value for money, great peanut butter – we got sick of running out fortnightly so the 2kg pail is definitely worth it.

    Remember to keep it mixed so the last 3rd doesn’t go dry!

  49. Ana (verified owner)

    Saving us from the panic of running out… for a week or two anyway, ha ha!

    So much easier to stir in the tub than in a jar (but: Forty Thieves, could you not devise a stirring paddle, please), and easier to eat out of, too. Our favourite way of eating this is by spooning it on to a banana, having a bite, spooning it on to the next bit, bite, etc. until banana runs out. (And THEN, you lick the spoon, yaaay! No point in wasting the unused pb, after all.)

    Does not prevent either of us from blaming the other for eating up the pb, though. Good thing we can order again, thus maintaining domestic peace.

  50. Ellie Harris (verified owner)

    The best peanut butter! We ordered a 2kg pail and finished it in under a month 😂

  51. Peter Schaap (verified owner)

    Great unadulterated Peanut butter, as good as always

  52. Grace Penman (verified owner)

    The best peanut butter! Absolutely delicious, always consistent, fantastic delivery and ordering system and amazing that there are various sizes available. We get the 10kg and go through it at a decent rate!

  53. John Le Riche (verified owner)

    Great product – not to much oil as others, great value for money and great flavour. We buy 2 x 2kg pales 1x smooth & 1x crunchy and mix them together…….AMAZING!!!!!!! We were using another brand of PB but now I honestly think we’re converted.
    So awesome job team, highly recommend.

  54. Grace Northern (verified owner)

    Amazing product and the best peanut butter – great consistency and the taste is amazing. Also very quick delivery and great ordering system.

  55. Jenni (verified owner)

    Delicious, great value and ideal consistency for all my peanut butter baking!

  56. Andrew (verified owner)

    We’re a large family so I tried a 10kg bucket thinking it would last us a very long time. It’s so good that it’s going down a lot faster than I thought it would.
    Now I’m thinking about it and I’m hungry, might have to go have some…

  57. Alicia Elder (verified owner)

    We love this peanut butter – it’s delicious & so much better than many other options. We’ll be through our 10l pail in no time! Thanks so much!

  58. Lorna Archer (verified owner)

    Great product and so easy to order on line as my supermarket keeps running out of Forty Thieves products. Great to add to cooking too.

  59. Croydon Hodge (verified owner)

    I am quite fussy when it comes to a good quality peanut Butter, and this is right up there. So happy with your product, I am converted.

  60. Ross (verified owner)

    Awesome peanut butter, it’s very popular in our house!!

  61. Alex (verified owner)

    4kg tub of crunchy PB is my go to order – best PB and the empty tubs make good compost bins for me and my flatties

  62. Sam Turner (verified owner)

    Lost count of how many tubs I’ve bought now. Hard to find quality PB for less than a dollar per 100g. Love it!

  63. Nat (verified owner)

    Great product, can’t believe how much PB we work our way through!!
    Ordered the 2kg bucket.
    Shipping wasn’t as fast as we would have liked.

  64. Robert Busnac (verified owner)

    Hi, delivery was blazing fast but the best part was opening the tub and loading my homemade breakfast toasted wholemeal sourdough and being blown away by the flavour. Even better than what I made myself at a bulk store in Thames. You can count on me for a regular order and when I open my bakery any baking with peanut butter will be done with Forty Thieves. Thank you so much ❤️

  65. Will (verified owner)

    Love having the extra pb volume. So much easier than buying a new jar each week. And so yum too!

  66. Nelson (verified owner)

    Forty Thieves peanut butter, you know its really great. I just can’t stop eating it although it’s getting late. Let’s open up another one and spoon it on some fruit. All those other peanut butters, I’ve given them the boot.

  67. Mary Rose (verified owner)

    We ordered a pail as a trial and we’ll be ordering a subscription next. Perfect texture and great flavour. We eat it on toast, in smoothies and straight from the spoon. Yum!

  68. Daniel Horgan (verified owner)

    So good, my favourite

  69. Daniel Horgan (verified owner)

    So good

  70. Hannah Tarr (verified owner)

    We look forward to our 4kg PB order every 4 weeks! Delicious in smoothies, sweet treats & sammies. A big hit in our household!

  71. Jess (verified owner)

    Best peanut butter ❤️

  72. adele

    The best nut butters!!

  73. Stef (verified owner)

    We’re a family of PB lovers & it’s the best peanut butter we’ve tried! The Carbon offsetting and sustainability efforts are also a winning factor in making this our go-to brand.

  74. Alex (verified owner)

    Best peanut butter and best value. We buy forty thieves exclusively now, and when we taste other brands the difference is huge! Forty thieves is by far the superior PB!

  75. Gwyneth (verified owner)

    Cheapest option for quality pb that we can find with the 10kg bucket. Great for everything.! Do find the smooth is not super smooth but still love it.

  76. Liam Cullinan (verified owner)

    Thank you for feeding mine and my friend’s peanut butter addiction. 10kg split between us, what a treat. If you ever pull up to a car park and see two friend’s with a 10kg pail of peanut butter, spreading s*** loads of the stuff on rice cakes, topped with bananas and honey, it’s us.

  77. Paul (verified owner)

    Great tasting crunchy peanut butter 🥜

  78. Quinn (verified owner)

    Creamy, tasty, nutty. it’s the best peanut butter I’ve ever had. Loving it

  79. Emily (verified owner)

    My family loves the Forty Thieves crunchy peanut butter. We are a huge PB consumer and buy the 4Kg pail. The PB is super tasty, lasts well and has an excellent texture. Plus love supporting an independent business who are committed to our planet and people.

  80. jess (verified owner)

    you can never have too much peanut butter – this stuff is fantastic !

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

SKU: N/A Category:
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop