Now On Shelf at The Warehouse

Available at 85+ Stores Nationwide Our award-winning Peanut Butter Smooth and Crunchy (and also SuperFood; Hemp, Nuts & Seeds) are now available at 85+ The Warehouse stores across New Zealand! When you’re on your weekend mission to grab some supplies, be sure to stop by the grocery section and pick up a jar 😉


WIN! ☀️💖 Whether it’s a long day at the beach, sunset drinks on the lawn or camping adventures far away, elevate your next alfresco adventure with this Ultimate Summer Kit, worth over $250! ☀️ Napoleon Goods Candy Pink Chilly Bin 13L🍹 12x Karma Drinks Raspberry Lemonade🥜 10x jars of Forty Thieves nut butters (5x Cinnamon Donut Peanut Butter, 5x […]

Meet our newest mascot, Mr. Smuggles!

Mr. Smuggles™️ has come to life! Our fun-loving peanut thief from the side of our Better-For-Kids Peanut Butters has come to life! Meticulously hand-crocheted here in New Zealand from quality cotton, this toy features a soft body, dangly limbs and a friendly smile. He’s the perfect addition to every adventurous child’s toy collection! Handmade in […]

Award-Winning Kid’s Butters!

Gold & Silver Awards for our Kid’s Butters! We’re thrilled to announce that our Cinnamon Donut Peanut Butter and Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butter have both won awards at the Inspire NZ Artisan Awards 2023!  Launched 3 months ago, these butters have not only received a tick of approval from parents and kids but now from […]

Christmas Cut Off Dates

Our factory doors will be closed between 3pm 22nd Dec – 8th Jan. Orders made over the holidays will be shipped from the 8th Jan. For Christmas: 🎄 For Summer: ☀️ Getting it delivered? Order before midnight Monday 18th Dec to ensure your order arrives in time for Christmas! * Click & Collect Pick up […]

(CLOSED) Colouring Competition: Design Your Own Toast!

Congratulations to our 6 winners!  The Competiton: Win 1 of 6 Forty Thieves prize packs! Our award-winning Cinnamon Donut and Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butters are super delicious on toast! Get the kids to draw their favourite toppings below and colour in the page for a chance to win 2x jars of each flavour. How to Enter: […]

How To Remove Our Paper Labels

Wondering how to remove the paper labels from your used nut butter jars? Here’s how: 1. Fill your jar with hot water from the tap2. Let it sit for a few minutes (be careful when picking up your jar afterwards as the glass may be hot to touch).3. Peel the label off the jar slowly. […]

Deliciously Disguised as Dessert!

Introducing; Chocolate Fudge Peanut Butter & Cinnamon Donut Peanut Butter Deliciously disguised as dessert, we’ve smuggled in the goodness of healthy peanuts, cashews and almonds to create a fudge-tastic, super-smooth chocolate butter and a donut-riffic cinnamon butter! Even the fussiest little eaters deserve real nutrition everyday and in their lunchboxes. With Forty Thieves, they can […]

1KG Peanut Butter Goodness

Introducing; 1kg King-Size Peanut Butter!  Fuel your Peanut Butter obsession with our King-Sized Peanut Butter! Crafted using top-quality Hi-Oleic Peanuts grown in Argentina and crushed into two magnificent textures, these 1kg jars are not only ‘fit for a king’ but for his criminal counterpart too…the kingpin! 50 Serves Per Jar! Superior in flavour, texture and now size, […]

    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop
      Calculate Shipping